Project

A Metahistorical Analysis of Expert Witness Historians in Cigarette Litigation in Australia, Canada, the Netherlands, and the U.S. after 1980: A Comparative Study of How Forensic Historians Shape What We Know and Don't Know About Cigarettes

Code
3E007418
Duration
01 October 2018 → 31 December 2019
Funding
Research Foundation - Flanders (FWO)
Research disciplines
  • Engineering and technology
    • Other engineering and technology
Keywords
Cigarette Litigation
 
Project description

The goal of this project is to better understand the historian's functioning and impact as an expert
witness. An expert witness historian testifies in court to help the judge and the jury understand
complex historical matters that are relevant to a case. Historical testimony plays a pivotal role in
cases in which the historical consciousness of manufacturers and the public about the harmful
qualities of cigarettes is important. My doctoral research questioned the compatibility of historical
research methods and forensic testimony in the U.S. This postdoctoral project adds two distinct
layers of analysis. Firstly, I will comparatively analyze how procedural rules in different legal
systems determine the impact of forensic historians. Secondly, I will measure the impact of
forensic historians on research agendas and cigarette historiography as well as on public
information campaigns on tobacco. I will compare legal codes, records of cigarette litigation,
formerly confidential cigarette company documents, cigarette historiography, and tobacco control
documents in four case studies: Australia, Canada, the Netherlands, and the U.S. after 1980. My
analysis will show how forensic historians in different countries have unevenly impacted our
knowledge of the history of the global cigarette epidemic. This combined approach is novel and
broadens our understanding of the functioning and impact of forensic historians in order to
encourage more responsible engagement in such practices.